The Honest LocalA community forum for neighbors
Compare Tucson and Phoenix · readings as of October 13, 2026

Tucson vs Phoenix

Tucson rents for $1,425 a month against Phoenix's $1,574 (Zillow, August 2026), and unemployment is 5.7% against 4.9% (BLS, August 2026). Among locals who answered, 1 of 11 in Tucson would move there again, against 0 of 4 in Phoenix.

By The Honest Local · the same public series for both places, side by side · locals’ verdicts from each thread
Tucson
City

Tucson

9%of 11 locals would move here again
28 in the thread
Phoenix
City

Phoenix

8 in the thread
The numbers source and period under each reading; the better reading is marked
TucsonPhoenix
Median rent$1,425 /mo$1,574 /mo
Listing price$372,500$475,000
Typical home value$321,918$405,689
Unemployment5.7%4.9%
Cost of living, US = 100108.6108.6
Violent crime, per 100kno reading696
Property crime, per 100kno reading2046
Regular gas$4.56$4.72
Air right nowAQI 23AQI 33
Temperature right now69°F73°F
Net domestic migration, latest year-350+22,256
Income taxflat 2.5% (2026)not in the guide yet
Sales tax5.6% state, 8.52% avg combined (2026)not in the guide yet
Property tax0.48% on owner-occupied (2026); ranks 14th on 2026 State Tax Competitiveness Indexnot in the guide yet

How to read this

Both columns come from the same public series read on the same day, so the comparison is fair even where the numbers are imperfect. Rent is Zillow’s observed rent index for the metro. Listing price is realtor.com’s median via FRED. Unemployment is the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ metro rate for the latest month. Crime is the FBI’s latest full year: a city reads its own police department and a state reads the FBI’s state summary. A state whose FBI file covers under 90% of its residents, or a city whose department’s file falls far short of its own count, shows no reading rather than a rate that reads safer than it is. Taxes come from each guide’s sourced figures and are missing where a guide hasn’t been refreshed yet.

The verdict line at the top is written from these readings by a template, not by a model, and it changes only when the readings do.

Missing here. violent_crime_rate, property_crime_rate, income_tax, sales_tax, property_tax. We leave a gap rather than estimate.
Sources and method
  1. Median rent: Zillow Observed Rent Index (city) · 2026-08; Zillow Observed Rent Index (city) · 2026-08
  2. Listing price: FRED · 2026-09; FRED · 2026-09
  3. Typical home value: Zillow Home Value Index (city) · 2026-08; Zillow Home Value Index (city) · 2026-08
  4. Unemployment: BLS · 2026-08; BLS · 2026-08
  5. Cost of living, US = 100: MERIC · 2026Q2; MERIC · 2026Q2
  6. Violent crime, per 100k: FBI · 2025
  7. Property crime, per 100k: FBI · 2025
  8. Regular gas: AAA · 2026-10-13; AAA · 2026-10-13
  9. Air right now: AirNow · 10/12/26; AirNow · 10/12/26
  10. Temperature right now: NWS · 2026-10-13; NWS · 2026-10-13
  11. Net domestic migration, latest year: Census PEP vintage 2025 · 2025; Census PEP vintage 2025 · 2025
  12. income tax: Tax Foundation 2026 · 2026-09-04
  13. sales tax: Tax Foundation 2026 · 2026-09-04
  14. property tax: Tax Foundation 2026 · 2026-09-04

Compare pages are built from the tape and each place’s sourced guide figures and refreshed nightly. Pairs people actually search for are indexed; the rest are served but not indexed.